Current:Home > StocksFederal judge dismisses racial discrimination lawsuit filed by former Wilmington police officer -Momentum Wealth Path
Federal judge dismisses racial discrimination lawsuit filed by former Wilmington police officer
View
Date:2025-04-14 02:29:40
DOVER, Del. (AP) — A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a former Wilmington police official who accused the police department of engaging in racial discrimination and improperly collecting and using data from seized cellphones, including her own.
Judge Mark Kearney ruled Monday that federal law does not allow Fray Coleman to sue public entities for racial discrimination in connection with an employment contract. Kearney also said Coleman had provided no basis for invalidating a search warrant that police used to seize her phone last year as part of a cold-case murder investigation.
Coleman, who was a master sergeant and in line for promotion to lieutenant, left the department in January after an investigation into statements she made regarding the 2007 murder of a friend of her daughter’s biological father. According to the lawsuit, Coleman told investigators in 2007 that a man named Ramadan was a suspect in the murder and that she would not be surprised if someone killed him. After Ramadan Dorsey was fatally shot in February 2008, detectives again questioned Coleman, who told them she had no information about his death.
Last September, cold-case investigator Stephen Rizzo reopened the Dorsey case. After interviewing Coleman twice, he told her she had an “inconsistent recollection” of Dorsey’s killing. Rizzo allegedly accused Coleman of withholding information because she was among the top candidates for promotion to lieutenant.
Based on information provided by Rizzo, a special investigator with Delaware’s Department of Justice executed a search warrant for Coleman’s cellphone in December, on the basis that she may have engaged in official misconduct and hindering prosecution. The warrant covered the time between her first interview with Rizzo on Sept. 30, and a second one Oct. 4.
Coleman was placed on administrative duty, but rather than report to her new assignment, she began a previously scheduled vacation two days early, according to court records. Defense attorneys say Coleman did not return from vacation but instead resigned. Coleman claims she was “constructively discharged.”
Coleman claimed that, while on vacation, she began hearing from several officers about personal information that had been created and stored on her phone. The information included photographs of her nude and wearing lingerie, “intimate videos” of her with her husband and text messages discussing how she and other black officers were treated worse than white officers.
Law enforcement officials submitted sworn affidavits stating that they were unable to search Coleman’s phone, meaning they would have been unable to disseminate any personal information extracted from it. Defense attorneys noted that Coleman did not give investigators her passcode and that from the time her phone was seized in December until she filed her lawsuit in April, the technology required to search the phone was unavailable to law enforcement officials.
Coleman, meanwhile, alleged that the police department has a practice of allowing forensic examiners to download the entire contents of cellphones subject to search warrants and allowing the authors of the warrants to conduct “fishing expeditions” for any “damning evidence.”
“Once the investigator finds useful information outside the scope of the warrant, they apply for an addendum or a new warrant to retrieve the information they already know exists,” the lawsuit states.
Coleman also alleged that authorities sought the warrant for her cellphone only because of her race. Her complaint included a laundry list of incidents that she claimed show a “pattern and practice” of racial discrimination within the department.
The judge noted, however, that a provision of federal civil rights law cited by Coleman does not allow racial discrimination lawsuits against police departments and other municipal agencies. That provision is instead aimed at prohibiting private parties from using race as a basis to refuse to enter into contracts. Kearney also said Coleman had failed to show that the search warrant, or the process to obtain it, was deficient.
The judge gave Coleman until Sept. 28 to file an amended complaint that provides facts that might support a civil rights claim against individuals acting “under color of state law.”
veryGood! (81574)
Related
- Don't let hackers fool you with a 'scam
- Dominic Purcell Shares Video of Tish and Brandi Cyrus Amid Rumored Family Drama
- What is spiritual narcissism? These narcissists are at your church, yoga class and more
- Senate rival Frank LaRose joins other GOP Ohio officeholders in endorsing Bernie Moreno
- Sarah J. Maas books explained: How to read 'ACOTAR,' 'Throne of Glass' in order.
- Huge Mega Millions and Powerball jackpots can be deceiving: How to gamble responsibly
- Jake Paul isn't nervous about Iron Mike Tyson's power. 'I have an iron chin.'
- Lions release Cameron Sutton as search for defensive back continues on domestic violence warrant
- NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
- Save 44% on the TikTok-Loved Solawave Skincare Wand That Works in 5 Minutes During Amazon's Big Sale
Ranking
- Pregnant Kylie Kelce Shares Hilarious Question Her Daughter Asked Jason Kelce Amid Rising Fame
- Skater accused of sex assault shouldn't be at world championships, victim's attorney says
- Dominic Purcell Shares Video of Tish and Brandi Cyrus Amid Rumored Family Drama
- Tiger Woods included in 2024 Masters official tournament field list
- The Grammy nominee you need to hear: Esperanza Spalding
- Dollar Tree is closing 1,000 stores, including 600 Family Dollar locations in 2024. Here's where.
- Lawrence County Superintendent Robbie Fletcher selected as Kentucky’s next education commissioner
- How one group is helping New York City students reverse pandemic learning loss
Recommendation
'Malcolm in the Middle’ to return with new episodes featuring Frankie Muniz
Savor this NCAA men's tournament because future Cinderellas are in danger
Tiger Woods included in 2024 Masters official tournament field list
AP Week in Pictures: North America
John Galliano out at Maison Margiela, capping year of fashion designer musical chairs
Millie Bobby Brown and Jake Bongiovi's Wedding Will Be Officiated by This Stranger Things Star
Amid migrant crisis, Massachusetts debates how best to keep families housed
New York Mets to sign J.D. Martinez, make big splash late to bolster lineup